20 March, 2013

MDB- The Top and the Bottom

There is something neat about focusing on the Snowy Scheme at the top of the predominant part, in water flow terms, of the MDB system on the one hand and the Lower Lakes and the Barrages at the bottom, on the other. 

I see better management of both as the most important issues in need of reform with the greatest opportunity for better outcomes both environmentally and productively. Yet the whole Plan process ruled out examination of the management of the Snowy Scheme and the Barrages.

The Big Issues

I recently attended my "umpteenth" Agricultural Outlook Conference in Canberra. I am very aware of the frailties of human memory, but did feel that it was one of the best I have attended.I was particularly interested in the FAO and OECD papers on food supply, population growth,etc.

The achievements of India and China,in lifting millions out of poverty seems to me to demonstrate what can be done and provides great hope for the future of the planet and mankind.

Two key principles give rise to my optimism-
  • There seems to be a consensus that global population will increase from the present 6.6bn to 9.1bn by 2050. This surely must place pressure on the environment.
  • It has been clearly demonstrated that as nations lift themselves out of poverty, with much improved education, particularly of women, population growth ceases. Meanwhile the very poor countries have the greatest population growth and population growth has effectively ceased in the developed world.
In any event, reducing disease and  poverty in the poorest nations seems to me to be the biggest challenge facing the world and is a great humanitarian endeavour.
I have great sympathy for the position of the "Skeptical Environmentalist", Bjorn Lomborg, who argues that rather than spending billions on attempting to change global temperatures we should simply adapt to what he believes is a warming reality and apply those billions to lifting living standards in the poorest nations.

This assumes that this can be done and that throwing money at the problem is the answer. It is, of course, much more complicated than that, with politics in sub-saharan Africa and elsewhere being a major stumbling block. However, the Indian achievements and the Chinese adoption of "socialism with Chinese characteristics" (free market principles/capitalism) demonstrates what can be done. Two papers at the Outlook Conference relate. The first deals with population growth and food production prospects. The second deals with food security and the importance of trade issues.

Murray Darling Basin and the Lower Lakes


I have long contended that the human mind has great difficulty in dealing with the mass of data which surrounds us. Particularly if you are of a curious nature.The only way we can cope is to make generalisations and, as it were, file them for future use. This carries with it the seeds of its own destruction. First, there is the problem of new knowledge making the generalisations invalid. I think it was Einstein who said "when the facts change, I change my position. What do you do ,Sir." Second, there is the problem of dynamism, in the sense of constant change.

In the Lower Lakes debate it is the largely the second dilemma that comes in to play. Few people seem to get their mind around the massive variability of our rainfall and thus river flows. We see people generalising about whether the Lakes were fresh or salty. The fact is they were both at different times, and often a "bit of both".

01 March, 2013

Murray Darling Basin Plan-The Truth Dawns

Quotes from a recent MDBA report, as so often happens, demonstrate how as managers get closer to the practical implementation stage they realise the errors in their theoretical planning.
Quotes
"Natural flows in the Murray–Darling Basin are highly variable, with water-dependent ecosystems developing and evolving within this flow environment. The high degree of uncertainty over future inflows and the variable nature of environmental demands point to the importance of flexible and adaptive institutional arrangements."
AND
"The way in which environmental water is managed and how environmental water requirements are specified will influence the environmental benefits and socio-economic effects associated with holding a given portfolio of environmental water. Many of the opportunities to improve outcomes involve environmental water managers using available flexibility to manage their water holdings. Exercising flexibility is likely to require more comprehensive governance."

The reality is that anyone with a basic understanding of this variability would never have asked CSIRO to come up with Sustainable Diversion Limits without specifically relating them to ever changing flow levels. To argue that the diversion limits are averages doesn't help as the "spreads around the average" are so large that the averages are statistically meaningless. As a consequence the base plan, on these grounds as well as others, is deeply flawed.

As I have consistently argued when dealing with this massive variability,two words should dominate your vocabulary-conserve and flexibility. It seems that at least and at last, the latter word is emerging. However, given this point and all the problems arising from writing what is basically an environmental plan, as distinct from a socio-economic and environmental plan, it would be best to rescind the Water Act (2007) and start again. This would have the further benefit of distancing the planning from the Millenium Drought environment where many natural drought impacts were falsely attributed to "over-allocation".


Nigel Lawson and The Royal Society


I have long admired Nigel Lawson's (Nigela's Dad!) consistent, questioning position. He is big on adaptation (if necessary), which we humans have proved to be remarkably good at. I would particularly draw your attention to his fourth paragraph. 

LORD LAWSON’S LETTER TO SIR PAUL NURSE
·         Date: 27/02/13
·          
Sir Paul Nurse
President
The Royal Society
6-9 Carlton House Terrace
London SW1Y 5AG
February 25, 2013
Dear Sir Paul
My attention has been drawn to a speech you gave last month at Melbourne University, in which you chose to criticise me by name in terms which bear no relation to the truth. In the interests of accuracy, I have obtained a full transcript. I recognise that, as a distinguished geneticist, you are not a climate scientist, and may therefore feel ill at ease discussing the complex issue of climate policy. But that is no excuse for wanton misrepresentation both of the issues involved and of my own position.
So far as the latter is concerned, you claim that I “would choose two points and say ‘look, no warming’s taking place’, knowing that all the other points that you chose in the 20 years around it would not support his case”. That is a lie. I have always made clear that there was a modest degree of recorded global warming during the 20th century (see, for example, my book An Appeal to Reason, which you have clearly not taken the trouble to read). However, so far from choosing any arbitrary ‘two points’, I was drawing attention to the fact that this warming trend appears to have ceased, since – contrary to the predictions of what you describe as “consensus scientific opinion” – there has been no further recorded global warming at all for at least the past 15 years, as even the IPCC Chairman, Dr Pachauri, has now conceded. Whatever the precise reason for this, it cannot simply be dismissed or denied.
Again, you assert that the reason I do not share your position is that I am one of those “who have political or ideological views that lead them to be unhappy with the actions that would be necessary [sic] should global warming be due to human activity… Because these actions are likely to include measures which involve greater concerted world action, curtailing the freedom of individuals or companies and nations, and curbing some kinds of industrial activity, potentially risking economic growth.”
There is nothing ‘political or ideological’ about my dissent from your position. It is true that I value individual freedom, and consider it immoral to be recommending measures which would hold back growth in the developing world and condemn hundreds of millions to avoidable poverty. But my objection to the policy you favour (see, again, my book, where it is clearly set out) is that it is not cost-effective (even if it were globally attainable, which the recent collapse of the Kyoto process suggests is not the case); and that, should an active policy response prove necessary, the only rational course is adaptation.
On the wider issue, I cannot accept your contention that only ‘scientists’ should decide the appropriate policy response. The role of scientists (or, rather, climate scientists) is to try and understand the complex science and its implications, and to convey that understanding, with all its attendant uncertainties, to democratically elected policy makers, who are then responsible for framing policy, taking full account not merely of the science but also, crucially, of the economics – which, insofar as you consider it, you appear to dismiss as not being “as evidence-based or as rational as science”.
In conclusion, I hope that, on reflection, you will recognise that there should be a difference between the behaviour appropriate to a President of the Royal Society and acting as a shop steward for some kind of scientists’ closed shop. Not to do so can only bring the Royal Society into further disrepute, which cannot be in the public interest.
Yours sincerely,
The Rt Hon Lord Lawson
Chairman
The Global Warming Policy Foundation

27 February, 2013

Modern Agriculture

This article in the Sydney Morning Herald by well respected journalist Paul Sheehan, really "got up my nose". So much so I sent off the following letter to the Editor. Sadly he/she didn't see fit to publish it.
"Paul Sheehan's perception of modern agriculture is severely flawed  (''We'll reap what we deserve'', February 18).  Instead of relying on some credibility challenged CSIRO reports and a "tree-hugging" Bob Carr, he should go bush and talk to some progressive, science oriented, successful farmers."



08 February, 2013

Leave Pass


LEAVE PASS-8th December,1954
As a 13 year old boarder at Canberra Grammar School, I was already"hooked" on the game of cricket. Thus, it is no surprise that I got "leave" to attend the match between the Prime Minister's Eleven and the touring Englishmen (who in those days played as the "M.C.C."), at Manuka Oval.

The attached very faded Leave Pass on Canberra Grammar School letterhead reads-
           
“8th. December,1954
Boyd has leave to go to cricket. Due back 5:30PM.
(sgd) Ron Morris”

I have crossed out the Rev. Morris' (Housemaster) signature and it has been replaced by “Keith R Miller”-the great Australian all-rounder-and “Robert G Menzies”-the cricket mad, great Australian Prime Minister!

On the back of the Leave Pass I have written, with some very strange spelling, the MCC batting scores. Note the quality of the team, Hutton, Edrich, May, Graveney, Cowdrey, Evans, Wardle.

At the Lunch interval my hero Keith Miller had been fielding on the fence near where I was sitting. I jumped the fence and went towards him to get his signature. One of the other players called out "look out Keith" and he jokingly ran off. In school uniform, replete with short pants, I took off after him. I chased him across the pitch to theother side of the field. There he stopped and said "seeing you've run so far I better give it to you", with which he signed my only  piece
of paper-the Leave Pass.

A short time later, along with a school mate-Noel Hickman-I was walking behind the then modest pavilion and saw "Bob" Menzies returning from the "Men's". I said to Noel "I should get his signature too." “Go on" he urged. I politely asked- "May I have your signature please, Sir"? Menzies, somewhat taken back, replied "you little horror"and proceeded to sign. He, good naturedly, complained about how difficult it was to write with nothing to support the paper.

Fifty eight years later, on Wednesday, 6th February, 2013 the first time an Australian team had played at Canberra, there was a One Day International (ODI) at the same Manuka Oval against the West Indies. Octogenarian TV commentator, Richie Benaud, referred to the 1954 game saying that it was the first time a match was played against a "Prime Minister's Eleven" in
Australia. He described it as a "charity match". One of his fellow commentators advised that Richie scored a century. It was this exchange that prompted me to dig out the Leave Pass and record this background to the faded document.

David Boyd
6th February,2013